Freedom/Free Will and Moral Responsiblity : A Reality or an Illusion?





Are we free or are we determined. Does being free held us accountable for our actions?  
Free will is a man's capacity to rationalise to be able to choose to act the way he wants to, moral responsibility is when he is accountable and responsible for his own actions. According Moya (2006.p.01) when it comes to moral responsibility; he argues that, " the property of human agents by virtue of which they are truly and objectively deserve moral praise or blame for some of their actions". Some argue that, there is not a sceptical challenge on this property. And free will is when free agents are who are the main actors who determine their own actions; in this way a man is held accountable and responsible for any action he does since he acts in his own accord-in all, "freedom is a necessary condition for moral responsibility (Moya.,2006.p.01). However, there is a scepticism on the notion that; having a free will and being morally responsible is impossible. 

Improbability of Moral Responsibility

 Sceptics of moral responsibility claim that moral responsibility is impossible whether determinism is true or not (French, Wettstein and Fischer, 2005.p.13). There an agreement that responsibility so conceived is impossible. It goes on to say that, nothing can be the cause of itself; so for a man to be truly responsible for his actions, he would have to be the cause[…] “therefore nothing can be truly responsible” (French, Wettstein and Fischer, 2005.p.13 ). Due that for him to be accountable for his actions, it would have to be one, who is of  free-actions, which are up to the agent (French et al., 2005.p.14). “And the free actions that are the ground of one’s responsibility must be rational actions, at least in the sense that they are performed for reasons, even if not for very good reasons” (French et al.,2005.p.14). 

 
If a person does for an occasion, he does what he does since of the way he mentally in some respect. Hence if what he does when he acts for an occasion is to be up to him; then how he is mentally in some respect, must be up to him. In order that he is responsible for how he is mentally in that respect (French et al., 2005.p.14).This might mean if one has a choice on what he does. There should be no determinism in a sense. For each man to be morally responsible for an action of his, that should occur if only he could have done otherwise, in in all determinism rules out alternative possibilities (Moya., 2006.p.10).  Strawson (1995.p.05) state that whether determinism is true or not it does not matter, mankind cannot be ultimately responsible their actions.   

Determinism and Alternative Possiblities

 



By Siya Manci, 19th July 2017

 Reference Lists

Moya, C.J.2006. Moral Responsibility: the ways of scepticism. Routledge.
French,P.A, Wettstein, H.K and Fischer, J.M.2005. Free Will and Moral Responsibility. Blackwell Publishing. Midwest Studies in Philosophy, Vol XXIX.
Strawson, G.1995. The Impossibility of Moral Responsibility. Springer. Philosophical Studies: An International Journal for Philosophy in the Analytic Tradition, Vol. 75, No. 1/2, Free Will, Determinism, and Moral Responsibility (Aug. 1994), pp.5-24:https://philosophy.as.uky.edu/sites/default/files/The%20Impossibility%20of%20Moral%20Responsibility%20-%20Galen%20Strawson.pdf

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Basic Education Should Be the Top Priority In Radical Economic Transformation

Image
Siya Manci, Dylan MacMann and Ikunda Maruma: Rhodes University  1.       Background Information to Education in South Africa When one looks at South Africa today, there is a great amount of poverty, inequality and unemployment affecting the lives of millions of South Africans. One of the most effective ways and possibly one of the only ways to alleviate these issues is through education. The term ‘education’ can be described as the process of facilitating, learning, or the acquisition of knowledge, values and skills (Writer, 2017). If we look specifically at the basic education system, we are able to identify many issues affecting the effectiveness of the policies. These policies have been put into place with the intention of addressing and reforming the education system, with the aim of alleviating the injustices of the apartheid era. South Africa’s past is one that simply cannot be ignored as it has dispositioned and disadvantaged the vast majority of South Africans with
Read more

Applied Anthropology in the Creation and Implementation of Policy

Applied anthropology as discipline, is important to bring a fair, just, understandable, functional policy framework that will suit the people who it is being implemented into or for. Cultural or societal values, virtues, norms, perception and perspective on economic, social, political, lingual, private and public realm must be brought into consideration when bringing any sort of policy. The discussion here is on how applied anthropology may be used in creation and implementation of policy.  The Language Policy: In the implementation and creation of policy, it would be wise for economists, sociologist, politicians, statisticians, bureaucrats and other policy makers to be alert about the culture or society the policy is being implemented for; that is, it should first take a language frame work that is suitable for the readers. Wardhaugh, R (2006:01) state how we need firstly to discuss the relationship between language and society as well as many functions of language with
Read more

From Positivism to Post-Positivism

Image
 The Rejection of Positivism to Post-Positivism  Positivism When the enlightenment took off in 18 th century, empiricism kicked in as the dominant explanation that knowledge is attainable through sense experience, during the arousal of experimental science the theory that all knowledge is derived from sense-experience. Stimulated by the rise of experimental science, it discredited innate and priori knowledge, beliefs as well as information through mentalism (Carruthers, P., n.d. p. 65).  Now, that’s how positivistic philosophy or ideology came in. in the 19 th to the 20 th century, the dominant philosophy in the West, was that: “any system that confines itself to the data of experience and excludes a priori or metaphysical speculations. More narrowly, the term designates the thought of the French philosopher Auguste Comte   1798–1857 “( Feigl , H., 2016). This philosophic ideology movement, adopted critiques’ from Comte, who’s the father of sociology  and th
Read more